Go back
Curatorial credits

“My Dear Arbur”: Gertrude Bell’s Letters to D.G. Hogarth

29 September 2022 | Lucy Smith

After writing a series of blog posts about T.E. Lawrence and the Jeremy Wilson Archive, I thought I would turn my attention to another figure who was influential in the Middle East and appears in the Hogarth Archive, namely the archaeologist, writer and political officer, Gertrude Bell.

Whilst the main Gertrude Bell papers are held by the University of Newcastle (see http://gertrudebell.ncl.ac.uk/), the Hogarth papers contain a not insignificant collection of Gertrude Bell’s letters to Hogarth, which reveal her personal, political and professional interests, as well as her feelings and thoughts about Lawrence.

Photograph of Gertrude Bell c. 1910. Magdalen College Archives, Papers of David George Hogarth, P452.

Traces of Gertrude can also be found in the Jeremy Wilson Archive, which often acts like a map tracing the many characters in Lawrence’s story. 

Gertrude Bell (1868-1926) was an Oxford-educated woman from a prominent manufacturing family in the north-east of England who became an archaeologist and traveller in the Middle East, and eventually became involved in its administration and politics, advocating Arab independence. She was the only female member of the Arab Bureau, and later held prominent roles in Iraq under its British Mandate, where she worked closely with Sir Percy Cox and King Faisal I. She was also instrumentally involved in setting up the Iraq Museum to display the country’s antiquities. Like Lawrence, she is often seen as a contradictory figure with fluctuating views embracing both Arab nationalism and British colonialism.

Bell’s letters to Hogarth address with surprising directness many of the subjects that would interest researchers today. We find her musing over the issues of Arab independence and administration in Iraq, contemplating archaeology and museums, and pondering the problems of Lawrence and his difficulties with writing and publishing Seven Pillars of Wisdom.

Bell often addresses Hogarth as “Arbur”, the shortened form of “Arab Bureau”, which was used in official documentation in the First World War. Hogarth became the Acting Director of the Bureau in 1916, but Bell continued to address him by this name long after the war had ended, suggesting a kind of preservation of their wartime relationship, and indicating her trust in Hogarth. In some of the letters, she discusses the work of the Bureau and apologises for neglecting her contributions, writing, “I’ll amend my ways with regard to A.B. reports”. Another time she is concerned to receive her copy of the Bureau’s publication, The Arab Bulletin: “It was a blow to find that while I had been pining for the Bulletin & wondering why it was no longer issued, my copy was lying at G.H.Q.”.

Bell discusses the political project of Arab independence, which she saw as compatible with a British mandate and influence. This proved to be an extremely difficult challenge, especially due to the many influences and groups in Iraq, which the British tried to manage and quell. Bell writes, “We’re trying to start an Arab state in the middle of pro-Turks & anarchic tribes, with every prospect of a Turko-Bolshevist Drive from the north before next summer, if not earlier. And every one comes in to give his opinion, or to seek consolation, or (but more rarely) to ask advice. In between their visits you try to get a little work done.” Other letters detail her excursions out of Baghdad “doing tribal geography & history”, and describe the assassination of the British officer Captain W.M. Marshall, the Political Officer in Najaf, as “a terrible loss”.

The letters also cover Bell’s archaeological and writing work. In a pre-War letter to Hogarth, she discusses the title of a book on architecture, suggesting “Palace and Mosque, a study in early M. architecture I, that too grandiloquent?”. The book was published as “Palace and Mosque at Ukhaidir” in 1914.

After her political role in Iraq was reduced, Bell returned to her earlier interests, and became instrumental in setting up the Iraq Museum in order to house Iraq’s antiquities and treasures. The letters include discussion of the “Antiquities Law” that Bell drafted regarding the authorisation of digs and finds in Iraq, which passed in 1924. In one letter to Hogarth, Bell raises concerns about the possibility of such a law creating “interference with the rights of the individual” by forcing “private owners of antiquities” to register “everything in their possession”. In a letter probably dating from 1926, we find Bell investigating buildings in which to house the museum: “I have been given a very good building in which to house this Museum & am spending all my leisure moments in getting into it. It will, I fear, look rather home-made, but at least if I can get our things safely lodged & adequately exhibited it will be something”.

Obituary: Gertrude Bell: Oriental Scholar and Administrator” by Valentine Chirol, The Times. 13 Jul 1926. Magdalen College Archives, Papers of Jeremy Wilson P450/R/ORR/6/1

In discussing Lawrence, Bell and Hogarth often seem to cast themselves in the role of concerned parents worried over a difficult child. She sometimes found him irritating, writing that “T.E. Lawrence has written a good deal of nonsense about Mesopotamia”. However, in 1925, after many years spent in Iraq, Bell returned briefly to the north of England for health reasons. During this time she read Lawrence’s manuscript and suggested several persons that could be potential subscribers to Seven Pillars of Wisdom, including Winston Churchill and Aubrey Herbert. However, she also became deeply concerned about Lawrence’s state of mind, during a time when he was revising Seven Pillars and was still trapped in the Tank Corps and unable to return to the R.A.F. In a very telling letter, Bell remarks that “the people who talk often of their end are not apt to precipitate it”, suggesting that Lawrence confided in her about his suicidal thoughts. Bell recommends that Lawrence be given “an interest” in Seven Pillars, in order to “postpone action” of this nature. However, she does not discount the possibility of such a course, writing that if life cannot “catch[…] you again”, “that’s then the moment to go”. Only a year later, Bell would herself die from an overdose that was a suspected suicide.

Obituary for Gertrude Bell by D.G. Hogarth. Magdalen College Archives, Papers of David George Hogarth, P452/REL/1/1 .

The Jeremy Wilson archive contains a newspaper clipping of Bell’s obituary from The Times of 3 July 1926, written by her friend Sir Valentine Chirol, in which she is described as an “Oriental Scholar and Administrator”. An article containing Hogarth’s own appreciation of Bell is stored with her letters to him (see article on right). We also have extracts from parts of her books that refer to Lawrence made by Wilson’s team, as well as reviews and other later articles on Bell. 

After her death, a stained-glass window was erected to Bell in East Rounton church, near her family home of Rounton Grange, North Yorkshire. One side of the window shows a scene of Baghdad whilst the other side shows the Great Tower of Magdalen College. Although Bell was a student at Lady Margaret Hall, it is perhaps fitting that some of her letters can now be found at Magdalen as featured in her memorial window.  

In this blog post, I have just been able to give a general overview of Gertrude Bell’s letters to D.G. Hogarth. The letters are open to researchers for detailed study, and appointments can be requested by contacting the archive at archives@magd.ox.ac.uk.

 

References

Letters of Gertrude Bell to David George Hogarth, c. 1910s-1926. Magdalen College Archives, Papers of David George Hogarth, P452/REL/1/1 .

The Letters of Gertrude Bell ed. Lady Bell. New York: Boni and Liveright, 1926. Project Gutenberg: http://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks04/0400341h.html 

“Gertrude Bell Archive”, Newcastle University. http://gertrudebell.ncl.ac.uk/